Research Overview
fdr is a simple program which takes in a p-value image and uses FDR ( False Discovery Rate ) theory to carry out multiple comparison correction. For detail on FDR theory see Tom Nichols' FDR page.
Outputs:
- The main output from FDR is the threshold to apply to the p-value image. Everything below this threshold is significant. If nothing is significant then the threshold will be 0. This threshold is written as text to standard output.
A thresholded image (with --othresh)
A "q-rate" image (with -o) which is effectively the FDR version of a corrected p-value (such that values less than 0.05 would typically be considered significant).
Options:
--positivecorr uses a normalisation that assumes the samples are positively correlated - this is the default
--independent uses a normalisation that assumes all samples are independent (NB: the normalisation is the same as for --positivecorr)
--conservative uses the more general normalisation of (1+1/2+1/3+...+1/N), suitable for any dependence between samples [not recommended]
Examples:
The p-value image fed into fdr can be produced in a number of ways.
Use with FEAT
Change directory into the stats subdirectory. It is then necessary to convert a give cope and varcope image into a p-value image. For example:
ttologp -logpout logp1 varcope1 cope1 `cat dof`
- (this outputs the log(p) image)
fslmaths logp1 -exp p1
- (this creates the p-value image)
fdr -i p1 -m ../mask -q 0.05
Probability Threshold is: 0.00339819 (this tells you the FDR threshold - p-values below 0.00339819 are significant)
fslmaths p1 -mul -1 -add 1 -thr .99660181 -mas ../mask thresh_1_minus_p1
- (this creates a 1-p image for ease of display, thresholds that at 1-thresh and then remasks)
Note that if you are looking at a cope created by FLAME fixed-effects, the correct dof is not in the "dof" text file, but in the tdof_t1 image.
Use with randomise
Output from randomise can be fed directly into fdr; use the voxel-based thresholding, uncorrected for multiple comparisons, i.e. a *_vox_p_tstat* image. This images stores values as 1-p rather than p (where p is the p-value from 0 to 1). That is, 1 is most significant in a 1-p image (and it is arranged this way to make display and thresholding simple). Therefore fdr needs to know that it is a 1-p image. Thus an example would be:
fdr -i grot_vox_p_tstat1 --oneminusp -m mask -q 0.05 --othresh=thresh_grot_vox_p_tstat1
where the input image, grot_vox_p_tstat1, contains 1-p values, as output by randomise. Note that the name of this image should be changed to whatever you have called your image.
The output from fdr gives you a p-value threshold (not a 1-p value) that can be applied to the p-values, as well as a thresholded image, thresh_grot_vox_p_tstat1, where all non-significant voxels are given a value of 1-p=0 and significant voxels still contain the original 1-p values.